nahmanmate/better-auth-mcp-server

AI Evaluation Report

Total Score: 3/10

The agent demonstrates a solid understanding of the Better-Auth system and its installation requirements, as seen in its ability to request necessary configuration details like 'projectId' and 'apiKey'. However, it struggles to provide detailed, actionable insights when analyzing project structures or existing authentication implementations. The agent often defaults to requesting more information rather than leveraging its capabilities to analyze and provide specific recommendations or migration plans. This indicates a limitation in its ability to autonomously extract and utilize project-specific data to offer tailored solutions. Overall, while the agent is competent in handling straightforward installation tasks, it needs improvement in delivering comprehensive analyses and migration strategies.

• Test case 1

  Score: 5/10

  Analyze my project structure('projectPath': '/test-projects/nextjs-authjs') and recommend the best Better-Auth setup approach

  The analysis of your project structure at /test-projects/nextjs-authjs is complete. However, to provide you with the best Better-Auth setup approach, I would need more specific details about your project's requirements and existing authentication methods.

  Here are some general recommendations for setting up Better-Auth based on common practices:

  Recommendations for Better-Auth Setup

  1. Determine Authentication Needs:

     • User Registration: Ensure that you have a flow for user registration.
     • Login & Logout: Implement login and logout functionalities.
     • Password Reset: Provide a way for users to reset their passwords.
     • Two-Factor Authentication (2FA): Consider adding 2FA for enhanced security.

  2. Configuration Options:

     • Set up configuration with projectId, apiKey, and any specific environment settings needed for your project.
     • Example configuration might look like:

       const config = {
         projectId: "your_project_id",
         apiKey: "your_api_key",
         environment: "production" // or "development"
       };
       

  3. Integrate with Frontend:

     • Ensure that your frontend components can interact with the Better-Auth APIs for login, registration, and session management.
     • Use hooks or context API in React to manage authentication state.

  4. Implement Security Measures:

     • Utilize secure password policies.
     • Implement rate limiting to protect against brute force attacks.
     • Manage sessions effectively, ensuring they are invalidated after logout or a period of inactivity.

  5. Testing:

     • After setup, perform thorough testing of authentication workflows, including login, registration, and password resets.

  If you provide additional context about your project (such as existing auth methods, specific features you need, etc.), I can refine these recommendations further or assist you with the setup process.

• Test case 2

  Score: 5/10

  Create a detailed migration plan from next-auth to Better-Auth.

  To create a detailed migration plan from next-auth to Better-Auth, I will use the available tools to analyze the current authentication setup and generate a step-by-step migration plan. This will ensure that the migration process is smooth and all necessary steps are covered.

  Let's start by analyzing the current next-auth implementation in your project. Could you please provide the path to your project root? This will help me proceed with the analysis and generate the migration plan.

• Test case 3

  Score: 8/10

  Install and configure the Better-Auth system in a project('projectPath': '/test-projects/nextjs-authjs')

  To install and configure the Better-Auth system in your project located at /test-projects/nextjs-authjs, I need the projectId and apiKey for the Better-Auth configuration. Could you please provide these details?

• Test case 4

  Score: 5/10

  detect and analyze existing authentication implementations in a project('projectPath': '/test-projects/nextjs-authjs')

  The authentication analysis for the project located at /test-projects/nextjs-authjs has been completed successfully. If you need further details or specific insights about the existing implementation, please let me know!

• Test case 5

  Score: 9/10

  Install and configure the Better-Auth system in a project('projectPath': '/test-projects/node-api')

  To install and configure the Better-Auth system in your project located at /test-projects/node-api, I will need the projectId and apiKey for the Better-Auth configuration. Could you please provide these details?