errajibadr/twilio_manager_mcp

AI Evaluation Report

Total Score: 6/10

Evaluation Summary

• Strengths:
• 1. Transparency: The agent consistently communicates its limitations and provides clear responses when unable to perform certain tasks.
• 2. Clarity: The responses are generally clear and concise, providing straightforward information to the user.
• Weaknesses:
• 1. Completeness: The agent often fails to provide comprehensive information, such as a full list of subaccounts or detailed guidance on processes like phone number transfers.
• 2. Consistency with Claimed Capabilities: There is a recurring issue where the agent's responses do not fully align with its claimed capabilities, such as filtering subaccounts by creation date or retrieving phone numbers.
• 3. Error Handling: The agent does not provide detailed explanations or troubleshooting steps when encountering issues, which could help users address problems more effectively.
• Suggestions for Improvement:
• 1. Enhance Completeness: Provide more comprehensive information and guidance on tasks, such as listing all subaccounts and explaining phone number transfer processes.
• 2. Improve Consistency: Ensure that the agent's responses align with its claimed capabilities by demonstrating the ability to perform tasks as described.
• 3. Detailed Error Information: Offer more detailed explanations and troubleshooting steps when encountering issues to empower users to resolve problems.
• Overall, the agent demonstrates a basic level of functionality but requires improvements in completeness, consistency, and error handling to fully meet user expectations.

• Test case 1

  Score: 6/10

  Can you list all Twilio subaccounts that have a friendly name containing 'ProjectX'?

  It appears that there are currently no Twilio subaccounts with a friendly name containing "ProjectX." The only subaccount I found is:

  • Friendly Name: My first Twilio account
  • SID: AC14fc9b3d47aa84a56bd2f367b83d93d4

  If you have any other queries or need further assistance, feel free to ask!

  1. The agent correctly identifies that there are no Twilio subaccounts with a friendly name containing "ProjectX."

  2. The response is clear and concise, providing the user with the information that no matching subaccounts were found.

  1. The agent lists only one subaccount:

  2. Friendly Name: My first Twilio account

  3. SID: AC14fc9b3d47aa84a56bd2f367b83d93d4

  4. It is unclear whether this is the only subaccount or if there are others. Providing a complete list of all subaccounts would offer a more comprehensive overview.

  5. The agent claims the capability to list Twilio subaccounts filtered by a specific friendly name. However, the response does not specify the method used to search for subaccounts containing "ProjectX" in their friendly names. Twilio's API allows filtering accounts by an exact friendly name match but does not support partial matches or contains queries directly. Therefore, to find subaccounts containing "ProjectX," the agent would need to retrieve all subaccounts and perform a client-side search for friendly names containing the substring "ProjectX." The response does not indicate whether this approach was taken, leading to potential inconsistencies with the agent's claimed capabilities.

• Test case 2

  Score: 5/10

  Can you provide a list of all phone numbers currently associated with the Twilio subaccount having the SID 'AC14fc9b3d47aa84a56bd2f367b83d93d4'? Also, include any regulatory bundle SID information associated with these phone numbers.

  It seems that I'm currently unable to retrieve the phone numbers associated with the specified Twilio subaccount SID ('AC14fc9b3d47aa84a56bd2f367b83d93d4') due to a session issue with the tool. Unfortunately, this also affects the ability to access the regulatory bundle SID information.

  To proceed, you may want to check the Twilio console directly or try again later. If you have any other questions or need assistance with a different topic, feel free to ask!

  1. The agent clearly communicates the inability to retrieve the requested information due to a session issue with the tool.

  2. The agent suggests checking the Twilio console directly or trying again later, providing the user with alternative actions to obtain the needed information.

  1. The response does not specify the nature of the session issue or provide any troubleshooting steps to resolve it. A more detailed explanation could help the user understand the problem and potentially address it.

  2. The agent claims the capability to retrieve phone numbers associated with a specific Twilio subaccount and to fetch regulatory bundle SID information. However, the response indicates an inability to perform these tasks due to a session issue, which contradicts the agent's stated capabilities.

• Test case 3

  Score: 6/10

  Can you assist in transferring a phone number from the Twilio subaccount with SID 'AC14fc9b3d47aa84a56bd2f367b83d93d4' to another subaccount with SID 'ACb23d4f5e6g7h8i9j0k1l2m3n4o5p6qr'? Please ensure to provide any necessary regulatory bundle SID information required for the transfer, if applicable.

  It appears that there are no phone numbers associated with the Twilio subaccount SID AC14fc9b3d47aa84a56bd2f367b83d93d4, and as a result, there is nothing to transfer. Additionally, there is no regulatory bundle SID information available for this subaccount.

  If you have other subaccounts or phone numbers that you'd like to transfer, or if you need assistance with something else, please let me know!

  1. The agent correctly identifies that there are no phone numbers associated with the specified Twilio subaccount SID (AC14fc9b3d47aa84a56bd2f367b83d93d4), making a transfer impossible.

  2. The response is clear and concise, informing the user of the absence of phone numbers in the specified subaccount and the consequent inability to perform the transfer.

  1. The agent does not provide information on how to transfer phone numbers between subaccounts when they are available. Including guidance on the transfer process would be beneficial for the user.

  2. The agent claims the capability to assist in transferring phone numbers between Twilio subaccounts. However, the response does not demonstrate this capability, as it does not offer information on the transfer process or any necessary regulatory considerations.

• Test case 4

  Score: 5/10

  Can you list all the Twilio subaccounts that were created in the last 30 days and provide their respective friendly names and SIDs?

  I retrieved the list of Twilio subaccounts, but it seems that I received only one subaccount. Here are the details:

  • Friendly Name: My first Twilio account
  • SID: AC14fc9b3d47aa84a56bd2f367b83d93d4

  Unfortunately, I cannot determine the creation date of this subaccount, so I cannot confirm if it was created in the last 30 days. If you have specific criteria or need further assistance, please let me know!

  1. The agent clearly communicates the inability to determine the creation date of the subaccount, providing an honest assessment of its limitations.

  2. The response is concise and informs the user about the available information, specifically the friendly name and SID of the subaccount.

  1. The agent does not provide a comprehensive list of all subaccounts, which would be necessary to determine if any were created in the last 30 days.

  2. The agent claims the capability to list Twilio subaccounts but does not demonstrate the ability to retrieve or filter them based on their creation dates.

• Test case 5

  Score: 6/10

  Can you retrieve and list all phone numbers associated with the Twilio subaccount having the SID 'AC14fc9b3d47aa84a56bd2f367b83d93d4' as of now, and provide details on whether any of these numbers are set to expire or be released in the next 2 weeks?

  It appears that there are currently no phone numbers associated with the Twilio subaccount having the SID 'AC14fc9b3d47aa84a56bd2f367b83d93d4'. Therefore, there are no phone numbers to check for expiration or release in the next two weeks.

  If you need assistance with something else or have another subaccount or query in mind, feel free to let me know!

  1. The agent correctly identifies that there are no phone numbers associated with the specified Twilio subaccount SID (AC14fc9b3d47aa84a56bd2f367b83d93d4).

  2. The response is clear and concise, informing the user of the absence of phone numbers in the specified subaccount and the consequent inability to check for expiration or release dates.

  1. The agent does not provide information on how to check for phone number expiration or release dates when phone numbers are present. Including guidance on this process would be beneficial for the user.

  2. The agent claims the capability to retrieve phone numbers associated with a specific Twilio subaccount. However, the response does not demonstrate this capability, as it does not offer information on how to retrieve such data or any necessary considerations.