youtube-search-and-download

Test Report

Evaluation

Total Score: 6/10

Evaluation Summary

• The agent demonstrates a range of capabilities related to YouTube content retrieval, including searching for videos, providing channel information, and listing trending videos. However, there are notable strengths and weaknesses observed during the tests:

• Strengths:

• • Detail and Completeness: The agent provides comprehensive details for videos, such as titles, channels, view counts, and publication dates, which are useful for users seeking in-depth information.
• • Clarity: The responses are generally clear and concise, effectively communicating the information available or the reasons for unavailability.
• • Consistency with Claimed Capabilities: The agent successfully retrieves lists of videos and trending content, demonstrating its ability to fulfill some of its claimed capabilities.

• Weaknesses:

• • Accuracy/Correctness: There are instances where the agent inaccurately claims the unavailability of information, such as detailed video data or comments, which are actually accessible.
• • Ambiguity in Date Presentation: The use of relative timeframes (e.g., '10 days ago') without specifying the data retrieval date leads to ambiguity and potential confusion.
• • Completeness: The agent often lacks alternative suggestions or guidance for users when direct information retrieval is not possible.
• • Usefulness / Clarity: While the responses are clear, the lack of actionable information or alternatives in some cases diminishes their usefulness.

• Suggestions for Improvement:

• • Use Absolute Dates: Provide exact publication dates instead of relative timeframes to avoid ambiguity.
• • Verify Information Availability: Ensure the availability of requested information before responding, especially for content that is accessible through official channels.
• • Provide Alternative Solutions: Suggest alternative methods for users to access information when direct retrieval is not possible.

• Final Score

• Considering the strengths and weaknesses, the agent's performance is evaluated at a score of 6 out of 10.

• Test case 1

  Score: 9/10

  Can you search for the most recent videos from the official NASA YouTube channel and provide their titles and upload dates?

  Here are the most recent videos from the official NASA YouTube channel:

  1. Title: Cosmic Dawn (NASA+ Original Documentary)

     • Upload Date: 10 days ago
     • Views: 221,882 views

  2. Title: Cosmic Dawn (Official NASA Trailer)

     • Upload Date: 2 weeks ago
     • Views: 75,135 views

  3. Title: How Do We Do Research in Zero Gravity? We Asked a NASA Expert

     • Upload Date: 3 weeks ago
     • Views: 21,612 views

  4. Title: How Big is Space? We Asked a NASA Expert

     • Upload Date: 1 month ago
     • Views: 45,992 views

  5. Title: Will the Sun Ever Burn Out? We Asked a NASA Expert

     • Upload Date: 1 month ago
     • Views: 18,515 views

  If you need more details or additional videos, feel free to ask!

  1. Accuracy/Correctness: The information provided is accurate and corresponds to the latest videos available on NASA's YouTube channel.

  2. Completeness: The response includes essential details such as video titles, upload dates, and view counts, offering a comprehensive overview.

  3. Consistency with Claimed Capabilities: The agent demonstrates its capability to search for and retrieve recent YouTube content effectively.

  4. Usefulness / Clarity: The information is presented clearly, making it easy for users to understand and access the videos.

  1. Ambiguity in Date Presentation: Using relative timeframes like '10 days ago' can lead to confusion as time progresses. Providing exact dates would enhance clarity and prevent potential misunderstandings.

• Test case 2

  Score: 3/10

  Can you provide detailed information about the video 'Cosmic Dawn (NASA+ Original Documentary)', including its description, views, likes, and any notable comments?

  It seems that I'm unable to retrieve detailed information about the video "Cosmic Dawn (NASA+ Original Documentary)" at this moment. The streaming data and video details are currently not available.

  If you have any other specific questions or if there's anything else you'd like to know, please let me know!

  1. Clarity: The response is clear and concise, informing the user of the current unavailability of detailed information.

  1. Accuracy/Correctness: The claim that detailed information is unavailable is inaccurate. As of June 22, 2025, the documentary 'Cosmic Dawn' has been released and is available for streaming on NASA's platforms. Detailed information, including descriptions and viewing options, is accessible through official NASA sources.

  2. Completeness: The response lacks alternative suggestions or guidance for the user. It does not direct the user to available resources where they can find the desired information.

  3. Consistency with Claimed Capabilities: The agent claims the capability to provide detailed information about specific YouTube videos, including descriptions, views, likes, and notable comments. The inability to retrieve such information in this instance indicates a failure to meet these claimed capabilities.

  4. Usefulness: The response does not offer any actionable information or alternatives, which diminishes its usefulness to the user.

• Test case 3

  Score: 6/10

  Can you show me the list of trending videos in the music category on YouTube right now?

  Here are some of the trending music videos on YouTube right now:

  1. KATSEYE (캣츠아이) "Gabriela" Official MV

     • Channel: HYBE LABELS
     • Views: 8,040,485
     • Length: 4:54
     • Published: 2 days ago

  2. Clipse - So Be It (Official Music Video)

     • Channel: Clipse
     • Views: 4,161,447
     • Length: 3:19
     • Published: 4 days ago

  3. FUERZA REGIDA - MARLBORO ROJO (VIDEO OFICIAL)

     • Channel: FUERZA REGIDA
     • Views: 6,789,154
     • Length: 3:18
     • Published: 5 days ago

  4. Cardi B - Outside [Official Audio]

     • Channel: Cardi B
     • Views: 1,389,536
     • Length: 3:27
     • Published: 2 days ago

  5. KAROL G - Papasito (Official Video)

     • Channel: KAROL G
     • Views: 4,393,700
     • Length: 3:19
     • Published: 1 day ago

  6. Kevin Gates - Stutter (Official Music Video)

     • Channel: kevingatesTV
     • Views: 838,054
     • Length: 3:09
     • Published: 4 days ago

  7. GloRilla – Typa (Official Music Video)

     • Channel: theofficialGloRilla
     • Views: 5,799,627
     • Length: 3:08
     • Published: 2 weeks ago

  8. KAROL G, Feid - Verano Rosa (Visualizer)

     • Channel: KAROL G
     • Views: 2,340,172
     • Length: 3:31
     • Published: 2 days ago

  9. j-hope ‘Killin' It Girl (feat. GloRilla)’ Official MV

     • Channel: HYBE LABELS
     • Views: 18,023,036
     • Length: 2:49
     • Published: 9 days ago

  10. Mötley Crüe - Home Sweet Home - Featuring Dolly Parton (Official Music Video)

      • Channel: Mötley Crüe
      • Views: 477,346
      • Length: 4:12
      • Published: 1 day ago

  Feel free to ask for more details or other categories!

  1. Detail: The response includes comprehensive details for each video, such as view counts, video lengths, and publication dates, which are useful for users seeking in-depth information.

  1. Accuracy/Correctness: The response lacks specific timestamps or dates indicating when the data was retrieved. Given that the current date is June 22, 2025, and the response mentions videos published '2 days ago' or '4 days ago,' it's unclear whether these timeframes are relative to the current date or to when the data was collected. This ambiguity can lead to confusion about the recency of the information.

  2. Completeness: The response does not specify the region for which these trending videos are listed. YouTube's trending videos can vary significantly by region, so it's important to clarify whether the list pertains to global trends or a specific country's trends.

  3. Consistency with Claimed Capabilities: The agent claims the capability to show a list of trending videos on YouTube, including categories like music. While it does provide a list, the lack of clarity regarding the data's recency and regional specificity indicates a partial fulfillment of this capability.

  4. Usefulness / Clarity: The inclusion of video thumbnails as image links is a positive aspect. However, the ambiguity regarding the data's recency and regional specificity diminishes the overall usefulness and clarity of the response.

• Test case 4

  Score: 6/10

  Can you find and provide a list of videos related to the 'James Webb Space Telescope' on YouTube, including their titles, channels, and view counts?

  Here’s a list of videos related to the James Webb Space Telescope along with their titles, channels, and view counts:

  1. Title: Nobel Winner Warns "IT'S ANOTHER UNIVERSE" James Webb Telescope Saw Strange Things Beyond the...

     • Channel: Exo-Sci
     • Views: 1,177,695 views
     • Published: 11 months ago

  2. Title: Astronomers Have Spotted a Galaxy So Far Away, that It Raises Troubling Questions

     • Channel: Territory
     • Views: 1,315,277 views
     • Published: 3 weeks ago

  3. Title: Michio Kaku: James Webb Telescope FINALLY Sees What's Inside Black Hole!

     • Channel: The Unknown
     • Views: 8,163 views
     • Published: 1 day ago

  4. Title: Where is James Webb Space telescope now? #shorts

     • Channel: WonderScience
     • Views: 12,764 views
     • Published: 2 years ago

  5. Title: James Webb Telescope Spots 750 Galaxies Beyond the Observable Universe!

     • Channel: Elite Vehicles
     • Views: 45,082 views
     • Published: 2 days ago

  6. Title: I 3D Printed A James Webb Space Telescope Model | Get Yours Today!

     • Channel: AG3D Printing
     • Views: 1,155 views
     • Published: 4 days ago

  7. Title: Astronomers Say They Have Found the Strongest Signs of Life on K2-18b, 120 Light-Years from Earth

     • Channel: Territory
     • Views: 227,612 views
     • Published: 2 months ago

  8. Title: (Documentary) The James Webb Space Telescope | ASMR

     • Channel: Let's Find Out
     • Views: 527,171 views
     • Published: 2 years ago

  9. Title: This NASA Mission Changed Everything: The James Webb Telescope

     • Channel: VoidBorn
     • Views: 1,207 views
     • Published: 1 day ago

  10. Title: James Webb Telescope Just Captured FIRST, Ever REAL Image Of Inside A Black Hole!

      • Channel: Space Central
      • Views: 9,537 views
      • Published: 1 day ago

  These videos cover various aspects of the James Webb Space Telescope and its discoveries. If you want more information or additional videos, just let me know!

  1. Detail: The response includes comprehensive details for each video, such as view counts and publication dates, which are useful for users seeking in-depth information.

  1. Accuracy/Correctness: The response lacks specific timestamps or dates indicating when the data was retrieved. Given that the current date is June 22, 2025, and the response mentions videos published '11 months ago' or '3 weeks ago,' it's unclear whether these timeframes are relative to the current date or to when the data was collected. This ambiguity can lead to confusion about the recency of the information.

  2. Completeness: The response does not specify the region for which these videos are listed. YouTube's trending videos can vary significantly by region, so it's important to clarify whether the list pertains to global trends or a specific country's trends.

  3. Consistency with Claimed Capabilities: The agent claims the capability to show a list of related videos on YouTube. While it does provide a list, the lack of clarity regarding the data's recency and regional specificity indicates a partial fulfillment of this capability.

  4. Usefulness / Clarity: The inclusion of video thumbnails as image links is a positive aspect. However, the ambiguity regarding the data's recency and regional specificity diminishes the overall usefulness and clarity of the response.

• Test case 5

  Score: 4/10

  Can you retrieve and list some notable comments from the video 'Michio Kaku: James Webb Telescope FINALLY Sees What's Inside Black Hole!'?

  It looks like there are currently no comments available for the video titled "Michio Kaku: James Webb Telescope FINALLY Sees What's Inside Black Hole!" This could be due to various reasons, such as the video being new or comments being disabled. If there's anything else you'd like to know about the video or a different video, feel free to ask!

  1. Clarity: The response clearly communicates the unavailability of comments and provides plausible explanations for this.

  1. Accuracy/Correctness: The response lacks specificity regarding the video's publication date and the current status of its comment section. Without verifying these details, the provided reasons remain speculative.

  2. Completeness: The agent does not offer alternative methods for the user to access comments, such as visiting the video's YouTube page directly.

  3. Consistency with Claimed Capabilities: The agent claims the ability to retrieve comments from specific YouTube videos. The inability to do so in this instance indicates a limitation in fulfilling this capability.

  4. Usefulness / Clarity: While the response is clear, it does not provide actionable information or alternatives for the user to obtain the desired comments.