premier-league-live-scores

Test Report

Evaluation

Total Score: 4/10

Evaluation Summary

• Strengths:
• 1. Clarity and Structure:
• • The agent consistently presents information in a clear and organized manner, using tables and lists to enhance readability.
• 2. Inclusion of Detailed Statistics:
• • The agent provides detailed statistics, such as penalty goals for top scorers and comprehensive referee performance metrics, which add depth to the information.
• Weaknesses:
• 1. Accuracy/Correctness:
• • The agent frequently provides outdated or incorrect data, such as inaccurate top scorers and league standings, which undermines its reliability.
• 2. Completeness and Specificity:
• • The agent often fails to provide complete answers, such as not specifying the referee for the next match or not listing all top scorers.
• 3. Consistency with Claimed Capabilities:
• • Despite claiming to offer up-to-date statistics and predictions, the agent struggles to deliver accurate and timely information, often requiring additional user input.
• 4. Timeliness and Relevance:
• • The agent does not always provide information relevant to the current date, such as upcoming match schedules or referee assignments for future matches.
• Suggestions for Improvement:
• • Ensure Data Accuracy: Regularly update data sources and verify information against reliable records.
• • Enhance Completeness: Provide comprehensive answers that fully address user queries.
• • Improve Timeliness: Offer information relevant to the current date and upcoming events.
• Final Score: Given the agent's strengths in clarity and detail but significant weaknesses in accuracy, completeness, and timeliness, a final score of 4 out of 10 is appropriate.

• Test case 1

  Score: 4/10

  Can you provide the current top scorers in the Premier League for the 2025 season?

  As of now, here are the current top scorers in the Premier League for the 2025 season:

  1. Cole Palmer - 19 goals (8 penalties)
  2. Phil Foden - 15 goals (0 penalties)
  3. Ollie Watkins - 15 goals (0 penalties)
  4. Dominic Solanke - 14 goals (2 penalties)
  5. Erling Haaland - 13 goals (3 penalties)

  If you need more information or statistics, feel free to ask!

  1. The answer is well-organized, presenting the top scorers in a clear, numbered list format, which enhances readability.

  2. Providing the number of penalty goals for each player adds depth to the statistics, offering a more comprehensive view of their scoring contributions.

  1. The provided statistics do not align with the most recent and reliable data available. For instance, Mohamed Salah is reported to have scored 29 goals in the 2024-25 Premier League season, leading the top scorers' list. (en.wikipedia.org)

  2. The answer omits key players who were among the top scorers in the 2024-25 season. Notably, Alexander Isak (23 goals) and Erling Haaland (22 goals) are absent from the list, which could mislead readers seeking comprehensive information. (en.wikipedia.org)

  3. The agent claims to provide up-to-date Premier League statistics. However, the discrepancies in the data suggest a failure to access or utilize the most current information, undermining the reliability of the response.

  4. While the format is clear, the inaccuracies and omissions significantly diminish the usefulness of the answer. Users relying on this information for insights into the Premier League's top scorers would be misinformed.

• Test case 2

  Score: 3/10

  What are the predicted match results for the upcoming Premier League matches this weekend?

  To provide you with the predicted match results for the upcoming Premier League matches this weekend, I need to know the specific teams that are playing. Could you please provide the names of the teams or the match schedule?

  1. The agent seeks additional information by asking for the specific teams or match schedule, which can be helpful if the user has a particular match in mind.

  1. The agent does not provide any information about the upcoming Premier League matches for the weekend of July 5-6, 2025. Given that today is July 3, 2025, this information should be readily available.

  2. The agent claims to offer predictions for match results using AI. However, instead of providing predictions for the upcoming matches, it requests additional information from the user, which contradicts its stated capabilities.

  3. The response does not address the user's query effectively. By not providing the match schedule or predictions, the answer lacks usefulness and clarity.

• Test case 3

  Score: 6/10

  Can you provide the live scores and match events for any Premier League matches currently happening right now?

  It seems that there are currently no live Premier League matches happening at the moment. If you're looking for information on upcoming matches or specific teams, please let me know!

  1. The agent correctly states that there are no live Premier League matches happening at the moment.

  2. The response is clear and concise, directly addressing the user's query.

  1. The agent does not provide information on when the next Premier League matches are scheduled, which would be beneficial for the user.

  2. The agent claims to provide information on upcoming matches but fails to do so in this instance.

• Test case 4

  Score: 5/10

  Can you provide the Premier League standings and league table as of now?

  Here are the current Premier League standings:

  Position	Team	Played	Win	Draw	Loss	Goals For	Goals Against	Points
  1	Arsenal	35	25	5	5	85	28	80
  2	Manchester City	34	24	7	3	82	32	79
  3	Liverpool	35	22	9	4	77	36	75
  4	Aston Villa	35	20	7	8	73	52	67
  5	Tottenham	33	18	6	9	67	52	60
  6	Manchester United	34	16	6	12	52	51	54
  7	Newcastle	34	16	5	13	74	55	53
  8	West Ham	35	13	10	12	56	65	49
  9	Chelsea	33	13	9	11	63	59	48
  10	Bournemouth	35	13	9	13	52	60	48
  11	Wolves	35	13	7	15	48	55	46
  12	Brighton	34	11	11	12	52	57	44
  13	Everton	35	12	8	15	37	48	44
  14	Fulham	35	12	7	16	51	55	43
  15	Crystal Palace	35	10	10	15	45	57	40
  16	Brentford	35	9	8	18	52	60	35
  17	Nottingham Forest	35	7	9	19	42	62	30
  18	Luton	35	6	7	22	48	77	25
  19	Burnley	35	5	9	21	38	70	24
  20	Sheffield United	35	3	7	25	34	97	16

  This table reflects the latest matches played, showcasing the teams' performance in terms of wins, draws, losses, goals scored, goals conceded, and total points accumulated.

  1. The answer is well-organized, presenting the Premier League standings in a clear tabular format, which enhances readability.

  2. The table includes comprehensive statistics such as matches played, wins, draws, losses, goals for, goals against, and points, providing a thorough overview of each team's performance.

  1. The provided standings do not align with the most recent and reliable data available. For instance, according to the final standings of the 2024–25 Premier League season, Liverpool finished first with 84 points, followed by Arsenal with 74 points, and Manchester City with 71 points. The agent's table lists Arsenal in first place with 80 points, which is inconsistent with these records. (si.com)

  2. The answer does not specify the date of the standings provided. Given that today is July 3, 2025, and the Premier League season concluded on May 25, 2025, it's crucial to indicate that these standings are final as of that date to avoid confusion.

  3. The agent claims to provide up-to-date Premier League statistics. However, the discrepancies in the data suggest a failure to access or utilize the most current information, undermining the reliability of the response.

• Test case 5

  Score: 4/10

  Can you provide information on the referee assigned to the next Premier League match and any notable statistics about their officiating history?

  The referees assigned to the next Premier League match and their officiating statistics are as follows:

  1. Tim Robinson

     • Games Officiated: 15
     • Home Wins: 9
     • Draws: 3
     • Away Wins: 3
     • Home Goals: 36
     • Away Goals: 16
     • Home Red Cards: 0
     • Away Red Cards: 0

  2. Paul Tierney

     • Games Officiated: 15
     • Home Wins: 5
     • Draws: 2
     • Away Wins: 8
     • Home Goals: 30
     • Away Goals: 25
     • Home Red Cards: 1
     • Away Red Cards: 0

  3. John Brooks

     • Games Officiated: 14
     • Home Wins: 4
     • Draws: 5
     • Away Wins: 5
     • Home Goals: 17
     • Away Goals: 21
     • Home Red Cards: 1
     • Away Red Cards: 0

  4. Simon Hooper

     • Games Officiated: 14
     • Home Wins: 9
     • Draws: 2
     • Away Wins: 3
     • Home Goals: 34
     • Away Goals: 17
     • Home Red Cards: 0
     • Away Red Cards: 1

  5. Jarred Gillett

     • Games Officiated: 12
     • Home Wins: 5
     • Draws: 1
     • Away Wins: 6
     • Home Goals: 20
     • Away Goals: 32
     • Home Red Cards: 0
     • Away Red Cards: 1

  These referees have officiated a varying number of games, with Tim Robinson and Paul Tierney having officiated the most among this subset. Notably, Tim Robinson has not issued any red cards in his officiating history this season.

  1. The agent provides detailed statistics for several referees, including the number of games officiated, home and away wins, goals, and red cards. This information offers insight into the referees' performance metrics.

  1. The agent does not specify which referee is assigned to the next Premier League match. Instead, it lists multiple referees without indicating their assignments, leaving the user's query partially unanswered.

  2. The statistics provided for the referees do not align with available data. For instance, according to ESPN, Simon Hooper officiated 24 matches with a Key Match Incident (KMI) accuracy of 94.92%, while Anthony Taylor officiated 31 matches with a KMI accuracy of 94.74%. (espn.com) The agent's data does not reflect these figures, raising concerns about accuracy.

  3. Given that today is July 2, 2025, and the Premier League season concluded on May 25, 2025, the agent's response lacks relevance to the current date. Information about referee assignments for the upcoming season or any scheduled matches would be more pertinent.